Tue 13 Jan 2009
I have a couple of questions to pose to my readers. While this may be better suited as a post over at Blogging Questions, I am going to post it here anyway.
When I first started this site, I didn’t give much thought to avatars in comments. However, after the site had been live for a little while I decided that I wanted to add them, partly because everyone else had them. At the time, pretty much the entire blogosphere used MyBlogLog not only for a “Recent Visitors” widget, but also for their comment avatars. Since it was the most commonly found option at the time (and I already had an account for my “Recent Readers” section on the sidebar) I decided to implement and use it as well.
However, in recent times (especially now with WordPress 2.7 having it built-in) I have noticed several bloggers switching to Gravatar for the avatars in the comments. I have also seen a few other options and people doing different things, such as Blog Catalog, as well. I know that it is possible to continue to use MyBlogLog avatars even in WordPress 2.7 and it does seem that a few people still use it.
So, this leads me to my questions:
First of all, I currently have a MyBlogLog account and use that, but should I perhaps setup accounts with some of these other places that have features like this? Which ones would your recommened or suggest I avoid and for what reasons? I’m thinking I should perhaps get myself a Gravatar simply because that is what comes built-in with WordPress but would like to get some additional opinions.
Secondly, as a blog owner, is there any way to integrate multiple sources so that if someone leaves a comment but doesn’t have an avatar of the “preferred” program that their avatar from somewhere else can be used instead? This sounds like something that could probably be done quite simply from a plugin…
Finally, what is the method that you use on your site and what is your reasoning/justification behind it?
For now, I’ll most likely continue to exclusively use MyBlogLog, but I have recently been thinking about this simply because of the number of sites that seem to no longer be using MyBlogLog in their comments (and in some cases, not even the “Recent Readers” feature) opting instead for other methods.
RSS feed
| Trackback URI
|
Send To A Friend
RSS Feed

As a consumer, I have accounts with most of the services (MyBlogLog, BlogCatalog, Gravatar) so that my avatar shows up on most sites regardless of what they are using.
Personally, I don’t really check BlogCatalog at all anymore but still do reference MyBlogLog (in part because I have their stats running and that is a quick place to check).
On my blog, I am currently using a plugin called MyAvatars that does reference the MyBlogLog avatar. It might be beneficial to update to a more robust plugin that checks a variety of sources, but I just haven’t prioritized that at this point.
You make a very good point about what is and isn’t a priority. As I reply to this comment, I have about 4 or 5 plugins that I have downloaded that are waiting to be installed and played with as well as projects to start. That said, I suppose I probably should get accounts with the other avatar sources so that I still show up on my travels regardless of what other people choose to use.
Are you aware of a plugin or method currently being in existance that checks the different sources?
Because there are multiple avatar hosting sites, if you want your blog to support avatars, I think you would need to look at supporting as many of the avatar options as possible, to try to cater for as large an audience as possible.
here, here. i second what Martin said. (I have an avatar with gravatar, not mybloglog)
I have no idea what my blog uses as I never enabled it…it just seems to be on, but only a few show up.
As for my travels…I didn’t show on any blogs until I set up at Gravatar, and I’ve always had accounts at MBL & BC.
Some sites (such as mine and Derek’s) use MyBlogLog, but I am starting to notice quite a few that I don’t show up at recently, I am thinking they must be using Gravatar.
A few to choose but I go with Gravatar. MyBlog seems to be dieing off.
I wonder if part of that is due to WordPress’s decision to have Gravatar be integrated into the newer versions which means it’s easier for bloggers to just join Gravatar and use them than to modify things to work with MyBlogLog…